Every year, as the holidays approach, we see the same thing: a surge of catering orders from families who have discovered that a spread of fresh Dan’s Bagels is the easiest, most delicious, and most crowd-pleasing way to feed a holiday gathering. Whether it is Thanksgiving morning before the turkey marathon, Christmas Day brunch, New Year’s Day recovery, or any gathering in between, bagels are the answer to the question every host asks: “What do I feed all these people without losing my mind?”
This guide covers everything: quantities by holiday type, flavor selections, cream cheese pairings, ordering deadlines, presentation tips, and the logistical details that make the difference between a smooth holiday morning and a stressful one.
Thanksgiving: The Pre-Game Spread
Thanksgiving morning is the most popular catering day of our year, and for good reason. The kitchen is about to be occupied by a turkey for the next eight hours. Nobody wants to compete with the bird for oven space. A bagel spread requires zero cooking, zero cleanup, and zero stress. Guests arrive, they eat, they are happy, and the kitchen stays clear for the main event.
For Thanksgiving, plan for 1.5 bagels per person. This is slightly less than a wedding or standalone brunch because guests are saving room for dinner. For a gathering of 20, order 30 bagels with 5 tubs of cream cheese. Go heavier on crowd-pleasers — Everything, Plain, Sesame — and add a few Cinnamon Raisin for the sweet-breakfast crowd. The Lox Spread cream cheese elevates the spread to “special occasion” status without any extra effort.
Christmas: The Morning Centerpiece
Christmas morning bagels have become a tradition for many of our regular families. The appeal is obvious: everyone wakes up, opens presents, and then gathers around a beautiful spread of fresh bagels without anyone having to cook. It is the gift you give yourself as a host — a stress-free morning that still feels special.
For Christmas, lean into the sweet and festive flavors. Include Cinnamon Raisin and French Toast bagels alongside the classics. Our Cinnamon Brown Sugar cream cheese is the star of the Christmas spread — warm, subtly sweet, and absurdly good on a toasted cinnamon raisin bagel. Add a tub of plain and a tub of scallion for the savory loyalists. Plan for 2 bagels per person — it is Christmas, after all.
New Year’s Day: The Recovery Brunch
New Year’s Day is recovery territory, and bagels are the ideal recovery food. Dense, satisfying, carb-forward, and requiring zero effort from the host. Order generously — 2 bagels per person — and go heavy on the classics. Plain and Everything will do most of the work. Add a lox station with smoked salmon, capers, red onion, and dill for anyone feeling ambitious. Coffee is non-negotiable.
Easter, Mother’s Day & Beyond
Easter brunch is a natural fit for a bagel spread. The timing is perfect — morning gathering, family occasion, crowd to feed. Mother’s Day brunch is another peak: treating mom to a beautiful spread of fresh bagels and cream cheese is a gesture that requires minimal effort and delivers maximum appreciation. For both, follow the standard 1.5–2 bagels per person ratio and lean into the seasonal flowers-and-brunch aesthetic for presentation.
Ordering Deadlines
This is critical. Holiday catering orders sell out. Our 48-hour production process means we have a fixed capacity for any given day, and holidays consistently hit that limit. Here are the deadlines:
- Thanksgiving: Order by the Sunday before Thanksgiving (5 days ahead)
- Christmas: Order by December 21 (4 days ahead)
- New Year’s Day: Order by December 28 (4 days ahead)
- Easter: Order 5 days in advance
- All other holidays: Order at least 3 days in advance
Late orders are accommodated when possible, but we cannot guarantee availability after the deadlines. We have had to turn away orders in past years, and we hate doing it. Please order early.
Presentation for Holiday Gatherings
A holiday bagel spread should feel festive. Here are the touches that elevate it:
- Use a large wooden cutting board or marble slab as the centerpiece. Stack bagels in a pyramid or fan them across the board.
- Transfer cream cheese from tubs to small ceramic bowls. Add a small spreading knife to each. Label flavors with handwritten cards.
- Surround the spread with seasonal elements: small pumpkins for Thanksgiving, pine sprigs for Christmas, spring flowers for Easter.
- Include accompaniments: fresh fruit, sliced tomatoes, capers, red onion, smoked salmon, and lemon wedges arranged on a separate platter.
- Set up the coffee station nearby but separate from the food. Include mugs, sugar, cream, and at least one carafe of decaf.
“A bagel spread is the gift you give yourself as a host: zero cooking, zero stress, and every guest walks away satisfied.”
The holidays are about gathering, not about exhausting yourself in the kitchen. A Dan’s Bagels catering order handles the food so you can handle everything else. Order early, set up the spread, and enjoy the morning with the people who matter.
Place your holiday catering order online.
Order Now
